KEEP PLANNING time / space / about #074 Lucian Staiano-Daniels Junction the C train, him
1. New York, London, Vienna, Berlin: Charette has traveled too much to tell. This same allcity in his dreams, same lean unsolving passages and the same damp stone. It’s not the city for the realism of where it’s placed, it’s the city for these stone shapes, for knowledge and effects of rain without its water or present feeling. Out smell of water and out weight. This same is the city he inhabits. When he’s awake Charette is the mind of this city, whichever city it is. Or he’s part of that mind: detectives as a group are the city thinking about itself. They swim against the same current, each in their own way: Charette and his others work together during an intensity, then they go back to their own workloads, each together, each alone. Right now Charette’s alone. That yours man? Nobody’s. I’ll take it if you don’t want. This one’s small enough. Guy punches guy in subway. Carbel the punchee; the puncher, Colby Cain. Racially aggravated assault. Colby Cain heads up a Chinese woman at turn stile and he tells her all so. He gives her all of it, go back to China don’t bring you here. Ching chongs her. Carbel steps in, tells him shut the fuck up she runs. Good for him? Good for her. Colby Cain turns on him: gives him dog’s abuse for a refugee and an insurgent. Better thank me for let you come to this country. Carbel snivels. He had his moment of strength and now it’s gone. Don’t know what to say. If and it’s over Colby Cain steps away, then he turns back and flails him a big punch to the jaw. That would be the hate crime. Rac. agg., he racked and he agged. What had to happen, and what had to refrain, to get these men to this place? A concatenation of forking trees, and the trees of forking trees, that two men intersected in this way and no other. The ratchet of the world clicks down one tooth a day, and it never clicks back. Charette’s job is to puzzle it out. 2. Charette may be a single, lonely, old, fat, ugly virgin, but he’s a single, lonely, old, fat, ugly virgin who thinks. His department has a shitty app, a filing system of the basement, and the subway’s terrible CCTV. Bullpen office not been cleaned and instant’s all they can afford. Rings down his mug’s white inside. Colby Cain’s been taped. Roams the rails that intersect and desect. Screams at staff. When Charette tracks something of data, he accretes out of his own self into a mind cool sifting and a pair of eyes. It takes a morning and a day to phone everywhere and collect references, and when they’re collated they’re frustrating. No criminal record til 34 then the convictions appear: at once and piling sharply. Which of? Frequent flyer in jail, by the ER. Constant minor assaults, abuse to people in the street racially aggravated. Hate crimes? Don’t know if you’d call them of such, I mean he is black. But there’s nobody he won’t rip shit of given a chance, and mostly immigrants. Well his family’s probably been here longer than—Yeah. Months later Charette IDs Colby Cain for someone else’s case and gets him locked up when he tries to push a stranger off a platform for attempt of murder. This month he’s unlike to do anything more than punch. Colby Cain’s coming back on bail for yet another case so Charette takes his chance and interviews him for his. 3. They vex severely at me. Colby Cain speeches sideways to Charette, spiky and jagged, potential indefinitude of referents. Who does, Colby Cain? This brutes. What do you mean by brutes, which brutes? The brutes of this whole world. Charette sips lukewarm instant and composes his mind: Leaving aside the whole world, can you explain what happened between you and Mister Carbel? He said you called a woman a racial slur and when he objected you called him a racial slur too, then you hit him. Insurgent he knocked at me, deliberately and he swore. Charette shows him the footage: Colby Cain, your explanation isn’t what we see here, do you want to change it? Not mine, half blind, he pushed me...where you can’t see him. This guy needs serious help but is unlikely to kill himself, and he certainly isn’t going to seek it himself, why would he? He never does anything wrong. 4. Grained feed: subway station glitches in the devil hour. Colby Cain’s memory the shove, the whisper behind his back. The brutes are everywhere, more persons than once. Gang stalk at him, falsely allegate. He’ll start a new job and think it’s over, then someone starts up and they too morph into a brute. Hound him from rail to rail, edges of these multifurcation, whisperings from bad corners. These things he experiences but cannot speak, they come out as: they vex at me. Officer. Carbel tethers himself to Charette by phone, wheedles, it’s been fifteen minutes and he has to keep asking did he do the right thing; uh huh, uh huh, sir I’m going to have to, I’m going to have to let you go, sir I 5. Every day Carbel phones Charette in uninterruptable. He clings like fog and adheres. He either came here young or he’s second generation and he’s terrified, cop voice on the phone the only other human being he’s talked to in days. If Charette stops listening, then he’ll really have nobody. He’ll fall into nothing at all. 6. Now the PD is a gigantic organization, within it every latticed tree has no idea what the roots and branches of any other are doing, they’re just each doing what they think when they think it, that’s the biggest most important police force in the country, more like a hundred organizations at once. Charette writes the case up and sends it to the prosecutor, which he has to do because you can’t trust the police to make fair decisions on a crime of racials and Carbel is not from here, but also because the prosecutors are perverse and short-timed they will find any stupid little excuse to find your case file is somehow deficient and refuse of charging until you comply with a shopping list of 21 stupid and impractical things, or they ask him idiotic questions that are already covered in the file, which see last letter so Charette and the prosecutors mail Colby Cain’s tatter file back and forth with a 5 week lag every time until finally the prosecutor admits defeat and charges him, 5 months after the punch. It’s during this delay Colby Cain tries to push someone in front of a moving train. 7. Charette outsources talking to Carbel to a victim witness volunteer whom he rejects to warn what a pain in his ass he is so she can’t get out of dealing with him in advance. Now Carbel calls them both: he believes in justice and wants to do his part to it, even though the hit no damage. 8. Colby Cain pleads not guilty. 9. Well he did hit him. 8. Carbel is desperate to connect to another human being. 7. Carbel’s brother and sister don’t speak to him. Charette retraces the forking paths. 6. Colby Cain is black and Carbel isn’t from here: whoever hit whom the city wants to take racism seriously so hate crimes have a maximum sentence of 3 years, which qualifies for a jury trial. Colby Cain insists on his right to trial. Carbel’s at his brother’s wedding when he says he’s going to have a seizure and demands his sister drive him home: when she refuses he falls and sprains his wrist so she’ll feel sorry for him, and she swears never to talk to him again. 5. Before the wedding his cousin’s driving someone to the airport and Carbel asks to ride along, he needs to get out more and he lost his car or license or insurance or something. She’d rather not: he keeps saying his health is so fragile and it’s 3 hours there and 3 hours back. He panics and begs, he knows she’s only near him out of pity, it would be easier for his family if he weren’t around. They bicker and forth for minutes and she can’t console him. The court has a backlog: when Colby Cain pleads not guilty, again, the trial date’s set 21 months in the future. 4. For 21 months the witness volunteer takes calls from the victim desperate for someone to talk to and reassure him he didn’t do anything wrong, which he didn’t, and for 21 months Colby Cain keeps going including attempt of murder, which they dial down to attempt of assault so nobody has to remand him because the prisons are overcrowded, this way he’s in and out. Carbel’s car: doesn’t register it, doesn’t insure it. At first he forgets. Letter after letter lets them fall unopen. He has an appointment for Wednesday but he doesn’t feel like a Wednesday and they should let him because he’s in bad health; when he shows up on Thursday the clerk is rude and he knows the DMV has it in for him. He panics. Less terrifying if he hates them back first. Cages a beater out someone he knows. Dust red, fading Nasa bumper sticker, Carbel’s dimly heard what Nasa is, and the exhaust’s sweet hydrocarbons. 3. 21 months later the trial is finally scheduled so they all pile up to the court at once, Charette and Carbel and the Chinese witness, and Colby Cain. The building’s a beautiful example of traditional architecture in these city: inside ceiling panels falling off and at least four buckets catch leaks of water. Charette can smell the gentle mold. As crowded as a bus. 21 listed trials, 13 courtrooms, 8 judges. A lawyer with 5 cases hisses on the phone to someone else while conferencing with Charette why nothing's happened yet, scrambling between the halls. Third day of this, 1 ongoing trial gets stopped and there’s a fight breaks out over which of the 13 other trials that haven’t started yet should start, in that room because there are no others (mildewed), and who gets adjourned to try again in another 21 months. Carbel perches in the witness care room, fretting under its mill of light. This country’s justice is why he’s here and not where he came from and he’s suddenly committed to contribute of it. The Chinese witness will testify and live, and forget; but in this way Carbel also insists on his right. Every time Charette sticks his head in he says, nothing’s happened and nothing’s going to happen. Carbel is closed to Charette, as Charette is to him: neither knows what the other is thinking. But Charette knows he is the iterative process of going to victims and witnesses and eroding their faith in the operations of things. 2. Charette has immense stubby hands and a heavy paunch. When he made detective he set his Chamelot-Delvigne down back of his desk and doesn’t carry it more, for comfort of the varnished belt. He’s ugly because his head like a slab of clay and his shirt half shoved in, has dandruff, old. But he moves like a vapor on fat little flat feet. He smells like nothing, not old microwaves and instant coffee which is the office smell, he is a mind who is looking. He’s a virgin because he is the vehicle of that mind, like a tower’s role is to hold the bells that ring the changes. Thinking of him having sex is as alien as it would be to that patterned sound, which is both material and immaterial. Trees branch out and branches lead back. Lines multisect their own trajectories. Taxonomies divide species and classify things and people. Genealogies trace the descents of people, DNA, languages, inspirations, teachers and pupils, and things that cause other things. Charette paths these plicative nets. When he chooses one thing he forestalls an indefinite array of somethings else. In his sleep he tracks ways through his city, and it’s every city he’s been in. Most of these traces reach destinations a rational mind would not be satisfied. He can’t identify the suspect. He thinks he knows who it was but can’t prove it. He thinks it’s a solid case but the prosecution says no not solid enough. He gets a charge but this matter probably isn’t going to come to trial for 3 years even though there’s no reason for it to take more than 3 months. He convicts the guy, who’ll be locked up for a year in a place that will make him a worse person, which he’ll come out and do it to somebody else. 1. Carbel doesn’t know the difference between inside and outside, public and private, dirt and matter. Leaves his front door open. Refrigerator door ajar. He feeds on sweet cereal, and buys it in bags: buys a new bag and sets it on top of the old one before the old one runs out, stale. His linoleum smells like saliva and rotten dog and is permeated of it. Came from another country but right now he’s barely conscious the difference between here and there. Someone else tugged him from one to the other. Someone pulled him here when he was a child or before he was born. He doesn’t know the difference between the right time to say something and the wrong time. He asks someone to get up and help him as the first spoon’s going into their mouth. When a woman tells him she broke up with her ex because two depressives shouldn’t date, he bellows “I see myself in that!” and waves his arms to the beat of his words. She recoils the flailing hands. She’s just met him, she wanted to get to know him had just given a cup of coffee, and she’s abruptly exhausted. She was making a sideways little self deprecating joke, but despite this flicker of self recognition Carbel can neither make that kind of joke or recognize it. If he doesn’t get complete togetherness it’s total rejection. He wants to need others and be needed. He wants to be inside the being of the other, he wants there to be pure open. Instead his friends withturn away, and no explanation. So he screams along songs about vindictive people and yips self-consciously at the end of each vocal scoop. I’ll play the main character in your bad dreams if you leave me. He has not yet left this metal awning town, his brother and sister are not yet the only people who speak to him. He has not yet made any decisions. The expanse of his life has not yet narrowed; and if his life runs backwards, his loneliness may still be redeemed. Colby Cain’s life is running forwards. Unseen to the law until something happens at 34 not other specified (head injury maybe?) then a sequence of deeds of violence. He’s surrounded by brutes, these entire people suffer from being a moron psycho. The course which leads your death, your commission of a crime, or your victim of a crime, is a series of events. Nodes in a series of bifurcations. Carbel and Colby Cain haven’t intersected yet, and Charette has not yet observed them. The future is behind them. Charette leans out his window with his thick arms on the sill, airing his fat in the cool of the day. Popped that screen out long ago. Scratches of conversations, extracts from letters, rejections, other people failing to do. He can remember them and they all annoy him in their own way, but he doesn’t need to remember them if he doesn’t want to.
*** Lucian Staiano-Daniels is the author of The War People: A Social History of Ordinary Soldiers During the Era of the Thirty Years War (Cambridge, 2024). 19 November 2026