KEEP PLANNING time / space / about #072 Israel A. Bonilla Luz Valduciel, 1943-2015
"Nothing will ever quench humanity and the human potentiality to evolve something magnificent out of a renewed chaos." Lawrence spoke of civilization. But we can speak of a single life: that which springs from the strife of a religious call and eventually crowns itself in a preternatural skepticism. It is a movement as uncommon as that of the parasomnist, who at the hour of rest buzzes with the enterprising spirit of full lucidity. Valduciel chased after the aseity of everything with which she came in contact, but her testimony always poured forth as a system of beliefs, as a lattice of unified truths. The force of negation that could do justice to multiplicity came late. Eternity fermented into a heartbeat. Valduciel was born in Bristol, near one of the Müller Homes for Children. Her caretaker, Mina, is said to have worked in the orphanage, though no records confirm this detail. In fact, there is little that confirms her existence aside from scant references found in Valduciel’s letters and interviews. The most sustained description belongs to a letter to Ronday in 1999:

We were never truly alone. She lodged strangers and fed them, asked about their lives and aspirations. I can’t remember anyone ever asking about her own life, but that was neither here nor there: she was, and that proved a self-evident source of strength. They sometimes defrauded her, but that too was neither here nor there. I once listened to her explaining to a maid that when things were unbearably painful, an angel took possession of her guts and saved her from contracting. The maid wanted a share of this power, but Mina could only acknowledge her ignorance. Some nights I caught her in dialogue with herself. Her eyes were always closed, and yet her whole body communicated a ravished attention toward the roof. She asked and answered in a melodious whisper.

We should be suspicious, however, of this tender remembrance. Not only is it recounted more than fifty years later, but it also adds too much new information. Mina had always been confined to three lines at most. Three lines, moreover, that ritually repeated her love for the orphans and her alacrity toward Valduciel’s needs. But reverence, self-denial, mediumship? Everything here exists in a void that suggests fabrication. Valduciel would never again linger on Mina as an autonomous being. So there is Mina, then a gap. If there is a wish to speculate, one should proceed in the negative. No conventional education. No conventional job. No conventional relationships. No vagrancy. No crime. The positive will come after her contact with people who do leave traces, but it will be unconvincing, close to the insubstantial Mina. Her meeting with Montiano Unzueta in 1964 adds, finally, an element of the factual. Then in his ascendance as translator and critic, Montiano kept an energetic correspondence with his younger brother, Gabro, the neuroscientist, in which Luz is a recurring name. Here is his account of their first encounter:

I have new evidence in favor of cigarettes. You’ll want to read closely this time. Last night I was at some fatuous congregation of like-minded whatevers. Unfortunately, I was sort of the center of attention thanks to my recent Nájera anthology. I tried to be evasive but courteous (not courtierly). No question resisted the immense gravitational pull of México’s nonexistence as a nation of poets (that it is considered poetic (picturesque, really) is another matter). “Which poet would you say he compares with?” “Is he part of a recognizable movement?” “Is he another Paz?” Now, here is the important part: there is a fine gesture that indicates to those around you that you need to smoke by yourself. (I’ll reveal it to you when you decide to come visit. It is infallible.) I reclined against a cheap fountain, and, after three cigarettes, a young, pale girl asked for . . . my lighter, which she ceremoniously used to burn off some wristbands. She didn’t explain this, but she did save me from my captors. New friend, I suppose. Imagine living without this addiction. Addictions are for the pure of soul, brother. Only they will live in astonishment.

The arch tone wore away as they deepened their friendship. Montiano turned restless. He was in love. The role of man of the world could have led to Osmond-like stratagems. Instead, one can sense in his letters the idyll of Ampère and Julie Carron:

As it began to rain, she lowered her voice and then grew completely silent. I didn’t react. She looked at the sky. The drops caused her eyes to struggle. I joked about her melancholy turn and the drops that now resembled tears. For a brief interval, she seemed to play along. But the rain cut short the performance. We sheltered near a dance academy, where the pupils, abstracted from the storm, followed their teacher through an inscrutable rendition of Stravinsky (or so I guessed). I stared at them, and Luz stared at me. Perhaps she was as puzzled as I, perhaps she indulged a passing thought. I read warmth. She untied the knot by pushing me into the storm, which almost immediately ceased. My uncanny abilities amused her.

Montiano read a lot of his own heart into Valduciel, but her ambivalence always comes through. So the result was not a temperate marriage. Indeed, an Osmond-like figure emerged from Montiano’s circle: Arcadio Lawson, who would determine the next twenty years of Valduciel’s life.   If we seek for the woman behind the love-delirium, Valduciel in her twenties appears confident, hermetic, and vibrant. Montiano, for all his intent calibrations, was a difficult match. He subdued his arrogance, but he was not a man of secrets and initiative. Like most men of letters, he was vocal about his merits and slow to extend his hand toward a world that paid its debts at rare intervals, if at all. To Valduciel, a life that orbited these concerns could be met only with a tactful scorn.   Arcadio Lawson was a young electrician with a numinous turn. Throughout the years, he had played with an interesting array of religious beliefs and soon commanded an audience that attended his improvisations; this same audience, however, had waited in vain for Lawson to become a leader. He refused because his low-commitment role as a showman at least guaranteed a regular stream of sexual partners and sycophants. A more ambitious role would entail responsibilities impossible to compensate: what was there beyond sex and recognition? More sex and more recognition? Valduciel was swift in her answer. Montiano’s circle admired Lawson insofar as he was a performer. But Valduciel detected a buried sincerity in him that she was eager to exhume. For two years she maintained the distance proper to a disinterested observer, during which Lawson frequently lost his composure owing to her rebuffs. Despite his princely attitude, he cowered at the thought of separation. He endured. He even saw himself soften his cynical posturing. When Valduciel corroborated the soundness of her intuitions, she removed the distance. They began living together in 1967 (and remained exclusive for a single year). It was only then that Lawson announced the publication of To Inhabit a Soul, the catalyst for their organization. Although Valduciel attaches her name only to the preface, it is well known that she is the author of the book. Quarrels abound over degrees of involvement. Some champion a typical configuration: Lawson as the figure touched by grace and Valduciel as the evangelist; that is, one as living voice and the other as translator. Nonetheless, most understand that Lawson had a minor role in the articulation of doctrine. We have no transcripts of his “improvisations” before Valduciel. What we do have are the notebooks she kept when they were acquaintances, which are full of corrections to preposterous ideas, and the notes she wrote for his speeches, which detail everything from the modulations of tone to the opportunities for digression. Nothing suggests any independent elaboration on Lawson’s part. To Inhabit a Soul is a bewildering work. It is both a diffusely argued metaphysical treatise and an overview of an incomprehensibly vast range of emotional experience. Its language convulses with unhappy neologisms yet resolutely grasps elusive psychological truths. There is a perpetual oddity that reminds one of Luther the conversationalist or of Powys the philosopher:

Mariage cannot and will not admit the perfusion of values, for it is born in the pistonmind, lover of isolated problems and isolated solutions, detractor of vales and glades, belittler to its very essence of communication, monopurposecrazed. Pistonmind of an enginebody that churns and churns without direction. Mengines and womengines with preset maximum pressure and maximum temperature, whether cast or forged. Mariage is a detailed instruction manual in a broken language, ultimately nonsensical. Values and meaning exist in ardherence, the copula of salamanders.

What doctrine lies buried underneath these snarled ruminations? The soul is an attainment. We are born as a sophisticated organic mechanism, and it is only through arduous liaisons (copulas) with the world that we inhabit a soul. There are, however, intervening abodes or animule. Through the physiological liaisons (orgastions) we inhabit fire (phiera), which has its center in the genitals. Through the meditative liaisons (minstrations) we inhabit pneuma (breth), which has its center in the brain. Through the visionary liaisons (unitations) we inhabit black light (umber), which has its center in the phantom body (engemon). Only a lifetime of abiding with the world (karezza) can disclose our home, soul, which ends the alienation from ourselves—embodiments, at last, of the divine. Valduciel is clear in one respect: this “home” has not been reached:

How close we have come to the soul! How close! But so long as we refuse method, there is no hope. Method, I say, and not ritual. Method, or the tidal concentration on the animula, is the last gift we received as organic mechanisms. If we persist in learning about the potentialities of method, we will some day be born as phieras.

Valduciel named her doctrine Plenism, trusting that her intended audience would not know about seventeenth-century debates on fluid mechanics (or maybe she savored calling all outsiders depletists). In any case, Plenism rose at the best possible moment; that is, when political disenchantment seeped into the projects of youth. Valduciel stood for pneuma. Lawson stood for fire. Yet Lawson was an imposing man, a full-scale incarnation of Valduciel’s word. As people joined, formalities compelled deference to Valduciel, but enthusiasm was all for Lawson. This would become a fatal issue only with the arrival of more formidable personalities: Damaru Baralt and Lutwidge Oesterrich. Baralt, a twenty-year-old mathematician, became a Plenist in 1972. Already at that precocious age he was a lothario and so quick to seek Valduciel, who had long been in an open relationship. They had a son in 1976, then a daughter in 1980. His descriptions of domestic life retain much of their mixture of softness and lubricity:

I am confounded at the post-orgasmic sight of her body. It is small, fragile, pale, covered halfway by a sprawling pitch-black ocean. It exists somewhere in the middle of the animate and inanimate. Until I notice the candlelight rhythm of her breathing. She lives like the quivering flame, and I am close to suppliance, but then she smiles. In the fullness of recognition, I lean and kiss her from toe to temple.

He was a restless defender of Valduciel and, in his zealotry, aggravated the conflict between her and Lawson. Once Valduciel decided to leave the Plenists in 1995, he planned for his children to stay with the organization so as to join her in exile. She refused and left abruptly for Italy with Ronday and Moricca. They corresponded warmly for the rest of their lives. Oesterrich, a fifty-year-old composer, became a Plenist in 1975. He was the man who singlehandedly brought about the apotheosis of Lawson and the departure of Valduciel. Before him regimentation was a matter of beliefs and conduct. After him it reached everything from clothing to transport. There is an extant letter of his where he lays out his motivations. Although it has been insistently discounted as apocryphal, it squares with the subject’s numerous comments throughout the years, as in this representative passage:

It is a miserable book, and it further proves my point about the whole situation: Lawson holds it all together. I doubt your average plenist has read more than a couple of pages, but your average plenist certainly falls under the spell of Lawson’s paroxysms. Have you heard him speak? He is incoherent for the most part. And that’s the thing. When he blurts out sense, it is glowing with the radiance of truth! I know she writes his “speeches” and so on. And yet I am sure, absolutely sure, those insights are his. The plenists want to bear his mark, and I will assist them.

Still, Valduciel proved exceedingly hard to discourage. She later confessed that her friendship with Felicitas Ronday and Larissa Moricca was the only reason she forbore almost two decades of conniving. In 1995, Ronday and Moricca suggested that Valduciel begin her life afresh. Plenism was now far from her original conception: it was a cult, indistinguishable in its paternal-minded obsessions from the crassest reveries of upstart megalomaniacs. She agreed. They traveled to Italy without pretensions. For two years, Valduciel lived within the sphere of her senses, grew aware of their generosity. In a letter to Baralt, she exults:

Everything is receptive to my presence, you see. The pines along the coast gather and dance one by one, as if to welcome me to their hyperindividual way of life. The waves throw themselves at my feet and, in a shivering caress, convince me of walking over the gentlest of fabrics. And the breeze! No sense escapes its laborious wooing. I am both its playground and its mate. The breeze, yes! It murmurs the most recondite meters and traces what I am at the present hour. Indoors we become acquainted with sin, the supreme abridgment. Outdoors we repent. Indoors I am Luz Valduciel. Outdoors I am Luz.

Yet as Powys says, “There have always been sun-obsessed souls and moon-obsessed souls.” Ronday and Moricca needed no more than their “knowledge of the sun” and their “conviction that the sun knew them, in the cosmic carnal sense of the word.” Valduciel drowned in the inarticulate ripples and splatters of her psyche-laden sensations. This communion with nature felt premature. Alone and with what little money remained from her Plenist days, she traveled to Greece, where she started work on Suicide Hedonics. It would take her twelve years to complete the manuscript, which was published in two volumes in 2012. In the introduction, Valduciel leaves no doubt as to her newfound skepticism:

Glorying in death, I intend to exalt life. The suicide knows that the world is so overcharged with value that our impotence to realize it within our fast-decaying flesh amounts to a comparative meaninglessness. But this is the perspective of someone who holds too dearly to life. I think of the child who, unbearably attached to its mother, at a certain point can bear no longer her absences and so relinquishes all emotion in a premature rehearsal of apathy. We ought to conjoin death, acquaint ourselves with her sudden breaches and savor them with that delectation we instinctively fall prey to when reality cracks. Then we will know that to realize the values of our world and avoid impotence it is imperative to know when to die. I am not against the suicide. I am against the being who renounces the feast of death with the timorous excuse of a weak stomach.

Suicide Hedonics is, to put it in Carlyle’s terms, “of boundless, almost formless contents, a very Sea of Thought.” And yet it still is a treatise of sorts. As declared in her introduction, Valduciel’s theme is the desirability of “building life toward death.” Unlike her existentialist forebears, she accentuates the voluptuousness of deterioration. The first volume deals with the positive stance, that is, the religious worldview, under which she subsumes art and philosophy. There are four sections, each one followed by a parable that usually involves a mother and a daughter: 1) “The Prophet Speaks of Future Life,” 2) “The Revolutionary Speaks of Fellowship,” 3) “The Inventor Speaks of Immortality,” 4) “Silence.” Throughout, she presents the constant intrusions of a relish for death that ultimately undermine every “naïve constructive effort.” The second volume deals with the negative stance, that is, the death-inflected worldview. It is divided into two sections, one followed by a list of exemplary lives, the other by a list of exemplary suicides: 1) “Life as a Modular Ruin,” 2) “The Significance of Method.” Her abundant autobiographical musings evince a Valduciel who experimented on others as much as she did on herself. Accordingly, this volume is rich in human observation. One of the few reviewers who took notice of the work commented that “perhaps the deeper truths of psychology can only be extracted from immense abandoned quarries that have filled with pristine water: Suicide Hedonics thus shares in the excesses of Kierkegaard and Fechner.” After publication, Valduciel returned to her family in England. She granted a series of interviews that coincided with Oesterrich’s revised edition of To Inhabit a Soul. A typical question: what do you think of the changes? A typical answer:

Oesterrich always wanted a timeless work, one to rival the sacred scriptures. I suppose I unwittingly wrote a book for a very concrete epoch in life: the epoch of discord. Twent to fifty? You must believe that there is some kind of god in you, who can design a plan beyond the limited scope of your consciousness and whom you can trust to act upon it. I may speak in metaphor now, but I did not do so then. I felt carried away at intervals by immense forces, forces which seemed to converge, and I tried to understand them.

Another typical question: is it true that you advocate suicide in your latest book? Another typical answer:

Death is an inevitability, no? There are many inevitable things against which we have protested with human ingenuity. We could not fly, we could not traverse the oceans, we could not communicate under countless circumstances. Then planes, then vessels, then letters, phones. And death? We create to outlast our lifespan, and we have even come to expect biological immortality. But these protests are wanting. They can be little else than pure imaginings. The human thing to do is to choose an appropriate ending, to arrange the ultimate symbol of what life has meant. Death need not surprise us anesthetized with extreme pain or extreme apathy. So I advocate for befriending death. We have everything to gain by inviting her in.

All money went to her children. If one were to trust the testimonies of everyone who last saw her, she was in an ebullient mood for most of 2015. But there is no need to put our trust in anyone other than Valduciel herself. In one of the last chapters of Suicide Hedonics, she describes the state of fulfilled disenchantment with life: “I have opened every door and every window available to the person I was handed out, mother, and I have traced every vista on its nerves until this person became a living tribute to the richness of its single vantage point, but I have to make room now that I am succumbing to the unnatural regret of being this person and no other.” She was found dead near a cliff in Braunton Burrows. At the inquest, the coroner’s officer stated that “the deceased seemed rather to be at rest.” In an unofficial capacity, he later added that “she looked like the lady who fell on top of a car, you know the one.”
***_____  Israel A. Bonilla lives in Guadalajara, Jalisco. He is author of the micro-chapbook Landscapes (Ghost City Press, 2021), the short story collection Sleep Decades (Malarkey Books, 2024), and the pamphlet Phoretics (Paradise Editions, 2025). His work has appeared in Your Impossible Voice, Firmament, Exacting Clam, new_sinews, Minor Literature[s], and elsewhere. 7 November 2026